What Are the Potential Disadvantages of Using Donor Eggs?

September 16, 2026

Deciding whether to use donor eggs carries both financial and emotional weight, so it is natural to want a full understanding of the drawbacks before you become invested in this path. Below are seven potential disadvantages of using donor eggs, what the current research shows, and the questions and concerns we hear most.

What are the disadvantages of using donor eggs?

Consideration What it means in practice What helps
1. No genetic link between you and your child You carry the pregnancy and give birth, but you do not pass on your DNA Understanding epigenetics, time, and talking with parents who have been through it
2. Higher risk of preeclampsia Roughly twice the odds compared with other pregnancies Telling your OB the pregnancy is donor-conceived so monitoring starts early
3. Time, with no certainty More than one transfer is common Frozen eggs to shorten the timeline, or a fresh cycle for every egg retrieved
4. Cost and insurance Only 15 states mandate IVF coverage, and few of those name donor eggs Grants, fertility financing, and program pricing you can compare up front
5. Emotional weight Grief and stress are common, particularly in the first months Counselors who specialize in third-party reproduction, and peer support groups
6. Choosing a donor Long profiles, competing priorities, and no objectively correct answer A written list of 3-4 non-negotiables, knowing your clinic's requirements 
7. Telling your child and family You decide what to say, when to say it, and to whom Starting early and keeping it ordinary, so there is never one big reveal

1. Coming to terms with the genetic loss

When you grow your family with donor eggs, one parent will not share a genetic tie with the child, and for many intended parents that is a significant loss to process. It deserves room, especially if you spent years picturing a child with your genetics or your family's features, and feeling sad about it doesn't mean you're unsure about the path ahead.

What the research says

A long-term study that followed egg donation families until the children were twelve found that parent-child relationships were as strong as those in families who used their own eggs through IVF, and the researchers concluded that the absence of a genetic link did not weaken family functioning.9

Weighing the pros and cons

While it's important to give yourself time to grieve the genetic connection, most parents eventually reach a point where their focus moves from what they are losing to what they are gaining, and the loss gradually makes room for hope.

If you are carrying the pregnancy, you still experience the pregnancy itself, give birth, and can breastfeed if you choose to, and your body has a measurable influence on how your baby's genes are expressed through epigenetics. And for every family, everything after birth is yours, from the first night home to every ordinary year of parenting that follows. For many families, that turns out to be most of what they were hoping for all along.

Victoria Niño, who conceived both of her children through donor eggs, described weighing it this way:

“Donor eggs had a high probability of working and also allowed me a chance to be pregnant, breastfeed and have a biological connection to my child. I desperately wanted these things. I wanted to be pregnant. I wanted to be a mom.”

She continues,

"Becoming a mother is not about what you give up, it's about all that you gain. Becoming a mother the hard way just means you gain that much more."

-Victoria Niño, mother via donor eggs

2. Does using donor eggs raise pregnancy risks?

A 2026 individual participant data meta-analysis in Human Reproduction Update pooled 2,747 donor egg pregnancies against 4,699 IVF or ICSI pregnancies and 33,323 naturally conceived pregnancies. It found about 2.4 times the odds of preeclampsia and roughly 2.9 times the odds of hypertensive complications overall, and the difference held whether donor egg pregnancies were compared with IVF or with natural conception1.

For context, preeclampsia affects roughly 1 in 25 pregnancies in the United States6, so an increase of that size still describes a complication that most donor egg pregnancies do not develop. It is also a condition obstetricians already screen for routinely, which means the single most useful thing you can do is tell your OB early that the pregnancy is donor-conceived, so blood pressure monitoring and preeclampsia screening are planned from the start.

3. Do donor eggs always work?

Donor eggs raise the odds substantially for most patients using them. However, they are not guaranteed to work on the first transfer. Nationally, 46.6% of transfers of frozen donor egg embryos led to a live birth in 2023.2 

Across our fresh matching program from 2012 through 2025, donors averaged 22.6 mature eggs per cycle, resulting in an average of 7.2 PGT-A normal embryos.7 Having several embryos to work with gives you a strong foundation for success, and it often means a second or third transfer can come from the same cycle rather than requiring you to start over.

In our frozen egg bank over the same years, 81.1% of patients obtained at least one blastocyst embryo and 60.5% obtained two or more.7 For most patients, that means a frozen lot delivers at least one embryo ready for transfer and often a second one in reserve, along with a shorter timeline and lower upfront cost than a fresh cycle.

4. Does insurance cover donor egg IVF?

Usually not in full. Most health plans do not cover donor egg IVF, and even plans that include IVF tend to exclude the costs tied to the donor herself, such as her compensation, screening, and agency and legal fees, although some will still pay for the medical side of your treatment, like the embryo transfer.

Twenty-five states have some form of infertility insurance law and fifteen mandate IVF coverage, but only a handful write donor gametes into the mandate itself. Delaware requires coverage for IVF using donor eggs, sperm or embryos, New Jersey requires coverage for IVF using donor eggs while expressly excluding a donor's nonmedical costs, and New Hampshire goes furthest, covering treatments associated with the procurement of donor eggs, sperm and embryos.5

If cost feels like the biggest hurdle, there are several places to look for help. We partner with CapexMD for fertility loans that cover both your program fee and clinic costs, program fees can be split into two installments, and we compiled a list of current IVF grants that may help with the cost.

See exactly what donor eggs cost with us

Our financial breakdown lays out pricing for the frozen egg bank, fresh matching and donor embryo programs side by side, along with what each one includes and your financing options. View the financial breakdown

 

A couple's hands resting together, one wearing a wedding ring, representing the emotional weight of deciding to use donor eggs

5. Choosing an egg donor can be overwhelming

It can be hard, largely because there is no objectively correct answer. You are weighing physical characteristics, medical and family history, education, personality, and often ethnicity, and no single profile will rank first on all of them.

A couple of things make it more manageable. The first is deciding, in writing and before you open a single profile, which two or three criteria are non-negotiable for you, since once those are settled everything else on a profile becomes a preference rather than another decision to agonize over. The second is working with a program that has already done the medical, genetic, and psychological screening, so the profiles you are comparing have all cleared the same bar. Our guide to choosing an egg donor walks through the criteria in order.

6. Talking about donor conception can be tough

The short answer is to start early and keep it ordinary, rather than saving it for one significant conversation later on. The ASRM Ethics Committee strongly encourages telling donor-conceived people how they were conceived3, and it is blunt about the reason the old approach no longer holds: with consumer DNA testing as widespread as it is, no program can guarantee that a donor's identity stays private.

The research on the exact right age is mixed. A systematic review in Human Reproduction found the evidence on disclosure timing inconclusive4, with some studies showing a modest benefit to telling before age seven and others showing no difference. What we see in practice is that families who fold it into normal, age-appropriate conversation from the first few years never face a single big reveal, because the child cannot remember a time before knowing. Our post on talking to your child about donor conception has language you can borrow at each age.

A mother lifting her young daughter in a living room, illustrating how families talk about donor conception in everyday moments

7. It can be an emotional rollercoaster

If you're feeling a lot right now, please know that is completely normal, and it tends to be heaviest in the first few months after donor eggs come into the picture. On top of the genetic grief we talked about above, you may be juggling decision fatigue, the stress of a medical calendar, and the tender question of who in your life to tell and when. If you have a partner, it's also common for the two of you to come to terms with this at different speeds, and that can feel lonely even when you're on the same side. None of it means you're making the wrong choice, only that you care deeply about the family you're building.

Today, there are many support resources available, including counselors who specialize in third-party reproduction, donor egg support groups, and simply reading stories from others who have been through it.

Do people change their minds about donor eggs over time?

Yes, often. Many parents say their first reaction to donor eggs was "absolutely not," and that it took months or even years of processing the loss before they were ready to look at it again. When they did, many found that donor eggs had become a path they could embrace with hope rather than one they were settling for.

"Though using a donor egg might be a loss of one dream, it also can be the beginning of another with the embrace of a proven technology that has created thousands of babies and happy parents for over four decades."

- Dr. Daniel Potter, reproductive endocrinologist

 

If you're exploring donor eggs, our guides to using donor eggs, how our egg donor agency works and our frozen donor egg bank walk through each path, and you can create an account to search the egg donor database whenever you're ready.

Keep reading

Sources

  1. van Bentem K. et al. The risk for the development of hypertensive complications in oocyte donation pregnancy: a systematic review and individual participant data meta-analysis (DONOR IPD). Human Reproduction Update, 2026.
  2. Society for Assisted Reproductive Technology. National Summary Report, 2023 reporting year.
  3. Ethics Committee of the American Society for Reproductive Medicine. Interests, obligations, and rights in gamete and embryo donation.
  4. Pennings G. Disclosure of donor conception, age of disclosure and the well-being of donor offspring. Human Reproduction, 2017.
  5. RESOLVE: The National Infertility Association. Insurance Coverage by State.
  6. March of Dimes. Preeclampsia.
  7. Donor Nexus. Success Rates and Donor Egg Costs, figures current as of September 2026.
  8. Braun C.B. et al. Trends and outcomes of fresh and frozen donor oocyte cycles in the United States. Fertility and Sterility, 2024.
  9. Murray C., MacCallum F. & Golombok S. Egg donation parents and their children: follow-up at age 12 years. Fertility and Sterility, 2006.
  10. Sebastian-Leon P. et al. Advanced maternal age was associated with an annual decline in reproductive success despite use of donor oocytes: a retrospective study. Fertility and Sterility, 2025.

Medical disclaimer

Guidance from your own physician and fertility clinic comes first. This article is general education about donor egg treatment and is not medical advice for your situation, and the figures here describe averages across large groups rather than a prediction for any one patient.

If you are pregnant and notice severe headache, vision changes, upper abdominal pain, sudden swelling or shortness of breath, contact your obstetrician or seek urgent care, since those can be signs of preeclampsia.

Last updated September 18, 2026. See the sources for every figure cited above.

Share this article
in X f
Donor Nexus Team

Donor Nexus Team

The Donor Nexus Team is the group of case managers, donor coordinators, and egg bank staff who run the agency's Fresh Donor Matching, Frozen Egg Bank, and Embryo Donation programs day to day. Since 2012 they ha…

More articles from Donor →
A family with their child

Ready for the next step?

If you are ready to get started or just need more info, contact us today.

info@donornexus.com +1 (949) 433 5635 (available M to F, 8AM to 4PM PST) 4675 MacArthur Ct, Suite 475, Newport Beach, CA 92660